Large-shouldered tops were popular in the United States in the 1980s because by that time the effects of feminism had trickled into professional environments, and women wanted clothes (specifically, suits) that made them look more commanding, more assertive - more traditionally masculine. Towards that end, I am sure they were successful; but I am equally sure that they did and still do make women much less attractive. And now, partially out of nostalgia for the fashions of a former generation, and partially due to social inertia, contemporary style calls tops with "puffy" or accentuated shoulders acceptable, "fun" or even attractive. Don't be sucked into the lie. The truth is that they are always risky, usually ugly and almost never a good idea.
If you think any of the women on the left look attractive, read the post titled "Because Of" vs. "In Spite Of". (All three are in good shape and their clothes fit well in all places but the shoulders.)
Clothes that slightly accentuate the shoulders might be mildly attractive on a girl that does not have a small waist-to-hip ratio; but in general, large shoulders make you look like a man and should be avoided.
Remember: whether consciously or subconsciously, men notice.
I'm glad this came up!
ReplyDeleteI have on black blazer I recently bought because I felt it was a wardrobe 'must' - not for work, but for school presentations. It's also popular to wear as a jacket with a dress in the evening or just during the day. Although I often see it on girls, looking good, I sometimes feel a bit masculine wearing it.
These are the types of outfits I would wear:
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-NZc2BrxuKbY/TV3MENWTURI/AAAAAAAAAFg/KjPLpt5yl3o/s640/OliviaPalermo-blazer.jpg
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_X7xCHk4hcOI/S9Z5DvB4ZJI/AAAAAAAAAcM/I_YMxWjZnbA/s1600/White+blazer.JPG
I still get attention when wearing it, but I'm quite girly-looking with long blonde hair. Would you say the attention I get is always in spite of the blazer, if I'm wearing it? Do men actually hate blazers?
I wouldn't say blazers are categorically a bad idea, but usually they are. The picture you linked to of Olivia Palermo is a good example of how a "blazer" can work. It is in quotation marks because, in my mind, the jacket she is wearing is hardly a blazer in the traditional sense of the word. Notice how well it fits her slender (i.e. feminine) arms. The waist is very trim and her shoulders are not too prounounced. I think other jackets might flatter her more than that one, but it definitely doesn't look bad on her.
DeleteThe one of Sarah Jessica Parker is a much better example of why a blazer usually doesn't work: baggy sleeves rolled up (looks sloppy and ill-fit), squared off and long bottom, wide and very "boxed" shoulders - all very squared, authoritarian, masculine: ugly. It clashes strongly with (i.e. ruins) the form-fitting, lace-lined dress and heels - both very feminine.
The type of jacket Olivia is wearing is sometimes difficult to find - even from designer shops. The fashion industry tend to favour regular blazers.
DeleteWhat do you think of this look (Olivia as well)
http://fauxnoir.tumblr.com/post/16894171750
Most girls think that's a good look. I think she makes it work even though it might be MORE flattering with a jacket with smaller shoulders. Like you say "in spite of" perhaps.
Hey, this is random but can you explain this:
ReplyDeleteMy friend has been dating a guy who claims he wants to keep things casual for now ... but yet he's asked her to move into his new house with him! She is considering (for HER convenience) and he seems excited about it. I don't get it.
Sounds like a typical case of a guy wanting to have his cake and eat it too - and I don't blame him: if your friend is going to let him have all the benefits of a serious relationship without making any of the commitments, that is her problem, not his. There is no question in my mind that she is making a bad decision. I am not saying it can't work out, but give the few facts you've stated, the probability is very low.
DeleteThanks, I'll slap some sense into her! But wow, I'm just surprised guys would be willing to keep a girl that close for the fun of it ... would that not make it difficult for him to date other girls etc ...?
DeleteIt isn't necessarily that he wants to date other girls - in fact, if he is asking her to move in I doubt that is the case. It is that he wants the option of breaking up with her eventually. In my mind, this is much worse of a situation, because she will get roped in emotionally, then dumped, which is a lot harder to recover from than being cheated on by a player who never connected with her personally anyway.
DeleteIn terms of style, how do most men feel about jewelry?
ReplyDeleteReal diamonds
http://www.millionlooks.com/images/nicole_kidman-nicole-kidman.jpg
Costume jewelry
http://www.msturman.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/gg-diorissimo-lily-mic.jpg
By 'costume jewelry' I mean non-precious stones. They have become more popular, and it's the type of jewelry they often wear in series like Gossip Girl.
I've often had the impression that men can find big necklaces or bracelets a bit 'much' and prefer a cleaner look, do you think so? Although I know big earrings are allowed, as you mentioned in a post.
I think jewelry can be very attractive when it compliments your look and your outfit. Some men are into a less "done-up" look than others, but the women that men routinely oogle over (celebrities, models, etc.) are often wearing jewelry. The right necklace draped across attractive cleavage is sexy as fuck. Large earrings are almost always attractive. Bracelets can also be sexy, and large ones will make your wrists look smaller (more feminine). I think the thing to be careful about is matching your jewerly to your overall look and the occasion, rather than wearing it or not wearing it.
DeleteI enjoy reading you blog very much, it has lot of very useful insight, but I have a question regarding this:
ReplyDeleteWouldn't women with very narrow shoulders benefit from this? I don't know exactly how it is percieved by men, but at least I've heard by some peers that narrow shoulder women look like lolipops, with a head to big in proportion to their shoulders.
Don't you think that to some extent having proportionatelly broad shoulders conveys elegance and good posture? Grecian sculpture style? I would like to hear your input.
I think you missed this part:
Delete"Clothes that slightly accentuate the shoulders might be mildly attractive on a girl that does not have a small waist-to-hip ratio"
Small waist to hip ratio means a waist that is wide relative to (not wider than) your shoulders shoulders, OR, shoulders that are thin relative to (not thinner than) your waist.
So yes, I do think it can be attractive in some instances, but they are few and far between. The point of the post is that you shouldn't be too ready to count yourself one of the exceptions to the general rule against wearing big-shouldered clothes; but that doesn't mean there aren't exceptions.
"small waist to hip ratio" has nothing to do with shoulders. I think you're talking about hourglass vs. pear shapes. I have a pear shape, with wide hips relative to my shoulders, and often wear blazers or tops with puffed sleeves to balance out my figure. The tops/blazers still have darts and are shaped well (meaning feminine), though.
DeleteI think your posts are great, but sometimes they miss the mark. Like this one- the girl in the black dress would look too bottom-heavy with that pleated skirt were it not for the puffed shoulders. The girl in the white blazer and grey dress (hot as hell btw... I wish I could wear that to the office, haha) almost certainly has more of a pear-shaped figure and the blazer balances it out. The girl in the middle, I see your point with though.
Good point. I meant to write "small waist to shoulder ratio."
DeleteThe post isn't titled "Don't Wear Large-Shouldered Tops," it's called "Be Careful About Wearing...." You might be one of the exceptions. But I have seen way too many women wearing them that shouldn't.
The while blazer look is horrible - easily my least favorite of the three. Blazers were designed for men and look too boxy/straight-edged on women. The girl is Kim Kardashian, so you are right about being bottom-heavy.
That's so interesting that you find the white blazer look horrible, when it was something that I wished I could pull off, haha. Shows you just how differently men and women think...
DeleteOn closer inspection, though, maybe a shorter, more fitted blazer would work better. You've got to look professional somehow. ;)
Did you see the comment above with this link?
Deletehttp://3.bp.blogspot.com/-NZc2BrxuKbY/TV3MENWTURI/AAAAAAAAAFg/KjPLpt5yl3o/s640/OliviaPalermo-blazer.jpg
It is an example of a "blazer" looking good, but as I said above, at this point it is hardly a traditional blazer anymore.
What about a dress like this?
ReplyDeletehttp://topten.lokoi.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Miranda-wore-a-plunging-black-dress-which-clung-to-her-outstanding-figure-Victoria-Secret-Fashion-Show-After-Party.jpg
Thats a perfect example of large shoulders looking bad. Don't be confused by the face that she looks hot in spite of the shoulders.
DeleteI just found this website and have been going through your posts. Some of your advice is interesting, especially things dealing specifically with dating/hookup interactions.
ReplyDeleteBut with fashion, I'm not sure whether you just don't care about or are totally oblivious to the fact that [most] women don't dress to attract men, they dress to impress their female friends/coworkers/acquaintances (except when we go out at night or on dates). I mean, it's not like men really know about current trends or typically compliment women on their clothing and shoes. Usually, it's other women who compliment us. Just thought I'd mention that.
I forget who, but someone once said "Women don't dress for men, they dress for other women. If women dressed for men, they'd just walk around naked."
It is precisely BECAUSE I am aware of this phenomenon that I write posts about fashion. Women who continue to ignore men's taste in women's clothing will fail to attract men. I am not saying that women have to follow my advice, but I am saying that there are consequences if they don't. At least after reading these posts they can make an educated decision to dress one way or the other (i.e. for women or for men).
DeleteMore than being failing to attract men, I think that women who dress fashionably/stylishly actually intimidate men. I think though, that most women who do this are, in fact, making an educated decision about what they are wearing. It's pretty hard to be oblivious to the fact that men probably aren't particularly attracted to colored tights or peplums. What's interesting is that this leads to the situation you talk about of men thinking a woman is attractive "in spite of" and not "because of" what she is wearing. So only the most physically attractive of women who make this decision and are still seen as attractive "in spite of" their outfits are hit on. Also, the guys that hit on them are usually the most confident/cocky because the clothes don't intimidate them.
DeleteI generally agree with you on this, I'm just commenting about my observations. Specifically being a fashion design major--I find it intriguing. My friends are some of the most attractive, confident women that I know and they purposefully make that educated decision to dress the way they like instead of wearing what would easily attract men. They definitely have less guys hitting on them than if they were wearing more conventional guy-friendly clothing, but I don't think they care. Maintaining their personal identity is much more important to them.
While you are correct in that often SOME women dress for other women and not for men, a blog like this is useful in helping to explain to some women what their friends and guys are too polite to tell them. The same women who love fashion but after years of dating still wonder "why am I still single?" or "I am wearing my new $500 dress, why is SHE getting all the attention?" This blog serves to illustrate what is going on in men's minds. As for blazers, even the demure one on Olivia Polermo, save that stuff for nights out with the girls where you couldn't care less about meeting a guy. For a date or when trying to meet a great guy, being bare shouldered or perhaps a tight thin sweater, rather than a boxy jacket is best. (assuming your arms aren't fat in which case you've got other things to work on)
DeleteIts all to do with that old signage...Bodylanguage...when it speaks to you...when you look at its shape,you are meant to answer...how do you answer..is what happens....meaning...some women dress to speak,some dress to attract general attention,some just want to impress others...in my opinion...when a woman dresses in a flirtious manner,she actually may..."want it"....?...but not in direct fashion,simply because she wants something to last....and last...
ReplyDeleteThanks for such a informative article. I am seeking this topic for one month.
ReplyDeleteintegrated receivables management
ReplyDeleteHow to Get an Ex Back
My boyfriend broke up with me its been 4 days now. We have been dating sense he was 18 and I was 22. She has just know turned 21. We have been dating for 3 years and 2 and half months. Through the years we have had a really good relationship it was serious and we really wanted to be with each other forever. Of course we had are arguments but nothing too bad. I know that these past 3 months I had taken him for granted thinking he would always be there but was wrong. he told me he didn’t want to be in a relationship that he wanted to take time with himself. But he was still kissin me and hugging me and telling me that he will always love me and I hold a special place in her heart. I realized that right before he done this that I needed to get my act together but I guess was too late. I really love this boy there is something different about him he is the love of my life and I want us to have a better relationship then ever before and I wouldn’t ever take him for granted ever again I really do want to marry this boy and he wanted that too but idk how to get him back with out being clingy and desperate. Obviously he needs his space because he cheated on me and this time I really need help to bring him back and marry me, one day i was searching online and i saw a good testimony of how Dr Joy a real Africa spell caster help to restored back broken marriage, getting ex back, fix broken relationship. so i copy his email via??? joylovespell@gmail.com and told him all my problems so he ask me not to worry that my problem are solve that with 2 days, i will get him back which i believe in and put all my hope on and to my greatest notice, after the spell my boyfriend who broke up with me gave me a call to apology and feel so sorry for what he did so my dear ones that is how i got my boyfriend back with the help of Dr joy the real spell caster so also email him now on via joylovespell@gmail.com.you can also call him or add him on Whats-app: +2347088404185.
I got separated from my husband 2 years ago. There was no communication between us. I was advised by families and friends to let go, forget the marriage and move on with my life. I didn’t want to marry someone else because deep down, I still love my husband. I was in so much pain and confused, until I read a testimony online on how Dr Odion reunion a broken marriage with the help of his love spell powers. I kept reading so many testimonies on how he helped to stopped divorce and bring back peoples ex-lover's to them, and my faith was renewed. I have to contact Dr Odion immediately, few minutes later, he replied and instructed me on what to do, after meeting up with the necessary requirement, 2 days later after he cast the spell, communication was restored between me and my husband. He actually knees pleading me to forget and forgive him. My relationship is now balance and my husband kept loving me every single day by day. His spells worked wonders and our relationship is now stronger then before, and nothing can separate us again. I visited so many website seeking for help, it looked hopeless, until I came in contact with Dr Odion the real man, who helped me to restore my broken marriage. If you're having similar problem in your marriage, you want your husband or wife to love you again, you have someone you love and you want him or her to love you in return, you are having any challenge in your relationship. Dr Odion SPELL TEMPLE is the solution and answer to your problem, contact him today via Email. odionspelltemple@gmail.com or Call or Whats-app him now +2347038832903..
ReplyDelete